HERE’S THE SECOND OF OUR 12-DAYS-OF-THANKSGIVING CORNUCOPIA: STRATEGIES, TIPS, TOOLS, RECIPES FOR WHAT’S ARGUABLY THE YEAR’S MOST GENEROUS HOLIDAY.
GO FLUID IN THE WAY YOU CELEBRATE THANKSGIVING. IF YOU DO THIS, AND PLAN AHEAD, I GUARANTEE YOU THE HAPPINESS AND EASE OF THE DAY WILL BE PALPABLY GREATER.
THE BEST TIP ON HOW? GIVE SOME THOUGHT TO UNDERSTANDING WHAT THANKSGIVING REALLY IS. AND ISN’T. LET WHAT YOU DISCOVER SHAPE THE WAY YOU CELEBRATE.
TURNS OUT VERY FEW “TRADITIONAL” ELEMENTS ARE ANYTHING LIKE CAST IN STONE. SOME AREN’T EVEN ACCURATE.
THE INSIGHT YOU’LL GET FROM DOING A DEEP THOUGHTFUL LOOK WILL — I PROMISE — SET YOU FREE TO CELEBRATE YOUR WAY.
ALL THIS, PLUS A DELICIOUS FEATURED PRE-THANKSGIVING RECIPE AND LINKS TO SEVERAL MORE.
(See button at the tippy-top of this post to jump to today’s featured recipe, CRUMBLE-BUMBLE BARS with Green Tomato Mincemeat Filling… or stay right here and read on for some interesting thought-food. You’ll also find hyperlinks to four other fabulous recipes scattered here and there.)
THE STORIES — PLURAL — OF THANKSGIVING
Thanksgiving — I’ve mentioned this before — is the one holiday I consistently celebrate. I celebrate it with joy, enthusiasm, a whole lot of really good food.
And, having outlived all but one of my blood relations, I celebrate it with my chosen family of friends. Some of whom I’ve celebrated with for decades!
And I think, if a person sets out to consider what Thanksgiving really is, both historically and personally, and in its largest context, the feast becomes as rich in meaning and integrity as it is in delicious dishes.
This consideration starts with asking, What is this holiday historically? How, when, and why was it founded?
And then: What is it to myself, to my family, to my country, to my world?
And then (because asking questions like these usually yields both insight and more questions); what would I like Thanksgiving to encompass, for me and those with whom I celebrate? How would I / we most like to spend the holiday?
From asking and answering such questions, we have the chance to make this holiday both unique and universal.
Unique? It can be particular to you and those sharing your table, right down to Aunt Sue’s cornbread dressing, and the mashed potatoes, which always get set out in the bowl your great-grandfather brought from Poland.
Universal? A good Thanksgiving can (and I think, should), also include elements which are far more vast, which transcend the customs of individual families.
For some aspects of Thanksgiving invite us to take helpings from the great universal contradictory table at which humanity — and each person in it — is briefly seated. For the span of their one and only life.
So please: get a plate, and check out the buffet. Pull up a chair.
THANKSGIVING DEFINED… AND REDEFINED, OVER SEVERAL POSTS 
Because this holiday has more layers than a well-laminated, perfectly flaky pie crust, I think it serves us to look at the answers to what is Thanksgiving? — as a multiple choice.
In this, Day Two, we’ll visit the first two answers, A and B.
I think you’ll be tickled to know that the A answer offers several recipe links, numerous ideas about menus and ingredients… and the universal “why” behind every one of them.
And in B, where we look at the history of this holiday in American, in comes a quietly radical, potentially liberating idea: you have the legitimate freedom to choose when you want to celebrate this holiday.
But there more multiple-choice answers and options in the next upcoming 12 Days of Thanksgiving posts.
See, when I began exploring the many legitimate answers to “what is Thanksgiving”, I realized the multiple choices and the options they opened up were getting a little long for a single blog post. As well as a little deep. With too many competing ideas.
Especially when the correct answer to this multiple choice series is ultimately “all of the above.”
And, after reading this, you can wonder about what C and D and E and maybe even F and G might be.
So. What is Thanksgiving, anyway?
THE ANSWER’S MULTIPLE CHOICE.
What is Thanksgiving?
A.
Thanksgiving is an end-of-season harvest festival, one of many celebrated throughout every region in the world, and in every era.
In virtually all of them, what’s celebrated is the wonder of what farms and gardens, fields and orchards, woods and streams, yield to human use. In all of them, appreciation and thankfulness are part of a feast which reflects this. In all of them, particular traditional dishes highlight the harvest foods, and share them with others: family, friends, the larger community.
A Take-Away: The essential ingredients that make up this holiday are the harvest (and by extension, food and the cycle of the seasons); celebration and thankfulness/gratitude; and some sort of collective get-together. This, to me, is the essence, the beating heart, at the center of Thanksgiving.
So: what foods that you enjoy most symbolize and express your idea of harvest? These are the ingredients that should find their way into your menu. You certainly won’t use just those ingredients, but to me they are the ideal, to-the-point-of-the-holiday foundation.
To my mind, any other elements of Thanksgiving except this one can be changed with impunity.

FROM GARDEN AND ORCHARD: MORE ON ANSWER A
Here are some thoughts on a few of the favorite, classic harvest foods of a North American fall:
- PUMPKINS & OTHER SWEET WINTER SQUASHES:
How do we love these hard-shelled, sweet, orange-fleshed members of the cucurbit famnily? Let us count the ways.* We bake with ’em: pies, breads, muffins: Of course there’s pumpkin pie (I will offer the filling for a fabulous vegan version in a future 12 days post) and perhaps pumpkin bread or muffins in the bread basket (these could also be served at a Thanksgiving or day-after-Thanksginng breakfast or brunch).* We simmer swoon-worthy soups with them: A voluptuously smooth butternut squash soup, not too creamy (since the meal is so rich overall) is a great edition to a Thanksgiving dinner. You could jazz it up with curry and ginger; you could make it a little sweet with apples, or do both. You could also make it pretty straightforward but give it a zappy topping, as in my Soulful Winter Squash Soup with Ginger-Apple Salsa. Or how about giving the potage a subtle hint of umami as in the beautiful Pumpkin-Tomato Bisque on pages 157-158 of my Dairy Hollow House Soup & Bread (Thirtieth Anniversary Edition); this was always a great hit at the inn and is one I come back to over and over.* We serve ’em on the side: What about roasted wedges or slices of winter squash, baked till they are tender within and caramelized without? They could be on their own, or done as a mixed vegetable dish, with onions and perhaps with halved brussels sprouts or cabbage wedges… perhaps drizzled with a sweet balsamic and tossed with dried cranberries or barberries and maybe pecans…* We stuff ’em! We will get into the whole turkey question later on in our Days series, but for now, just let me say… if you are a vegetarian or vegan, or are cooking for someone who is, and you’re cogitating on a turkey “instead of” that still gives a nod to tradition… go ahead and make your favorite meat-free dressing or stuffing, and bake it in a hubbard squash, or individual mini-pumpkins. Yum!* As table decoration: While I confess that it’s incomprehensible to me that someone might actually not like squash if prepared well in one of these iterations, there are still all these glorious little warty funny looking squashes that, while not poisonous, certainly are not terribly edible. But they can be part of the party! Just put ’em on the table or buffet or incorporate them into an arrangement with the fall-colored chrysanthemums…
- FALL FRUITS:
Spring has its strawberries, summer its blueberries, raspberries, black berries, and stone-fruits like peaches and apricots. But fall brings us apples, pears, cranberries, quinces (if you’re lucky enough to find ’em)…each an invitation and part of harvest.
*Apples? I combine ’em with the winter squashes sometimes, as you can see from the references above, but, of course, there MUST be a deep dish apple pie with a perfect flaky crust (I amp up the apple-ness by adding some unsweetened plain apple butter as part of the sweetening… and I also add a little fresh-ground black pepper to the traditional apple-pie spices for some zzzh-ing).Except, sometimes I do the opposite instead, making a shallower but very delicious tarte tatin. And sometimes I make an apple-cranberry pie or cobbler or crisp. Those cranberry polka-dots of bright color and flavor add a new dimension (at other times, I go for straight apple and leave the cranberries to be condiments).* Pears? You couldn’t go wrong with my truly delectable Maple-Pecan Pear Upside-Down Cake, and many people find a simple cake and less messy than the whole production of messing a flour-covered counter and pastry-rolling. Even easier: a pear strudel done with commercially filo dough surprises and wows guests every time, but is oh so simple. Yet another pear-perfect offering, for those who aren’t fanciers of cakes and pastries or are trying to cut down on sugar or fat or avoid gluten: poach the pears, in red wine and apple cider. When the pears are poached, remove them from the poaching liquid and boil it down to a syrup.
* Quinces: when it comes to usage think of a quince as an extra-hard, extra-fragrant apple… but its flavor is simply intoxicating, sort of floral plus apple plus pear. I usually simply poach them and serve over vanilla ice cream with a shortbread or other not-too-sweet cookie on the side, but that’s not all that Thanksgiving-y to my mind. I love David Leibowitz‘s ideas on quince use : a quince tarte tatin (great idea), in a fruit crisp. And though I haven’t tried it get, I bet a filling of barely-tender quince cubes, mashed into their sweetened poaching liquid, would make a great alternative filling for the featured recipe below, Crumble-Bumble Bars. - STUFF YOU’VE ALREADY HARVESTED AND PUT UP: If you are the kind of person who cans, pickles, and preserves, hanksgiving is the meal at which you can show off yours chow-chow, corn relish, bread-and-butter pickles and of course your Green Tomato Mincemeat!
- SWEET POTATOES: but later in our series for them.
- HARDY WINTER VEGETABLES: many vegetables just do better when the weather turns a little cooler. Many are brassicas, in the cabbage family: brussels sprouts, broccoli, cauliflower, broccoli rabe, kale. But some root vegetables: notably carrots, turnips, and beets, turn much sweeter as the temperature drops. More ideas on them, too, coming up.
What is Thanksgiving?
B.
Thanksgiving is an American holiday, our country’s iteration of the harvest festival.
Celebrated nationally on and off since 1789, George Washington got the ball rolling with a proclamation. But the day was observed only intermittently until 1863, when Abraham Lincoln proclaimed the last Thursday in November as a national day of “Thanksgiving and Praise.”
There was a reason why it became official just then: in 1863 we were a bitterly divided nation (more so than at any other time in our history, even the edgy present). The country was in the throes of the Civil War, North and South cleaved in two.
But less often considered is that the federal government remained in another dividing storm about who and what we were. There was deep, cruel, bloody, oppressive conflict with the people who were here first, Native Americans.
Lincoln’s proclaiming of Thanksgiving as an official holiday was in part an act of what we might call aspirational propaganda: he hoped it might bind some of the division. Just listen to the language he used: he asked the American people, “with humble penitence for our national perverseness and disobedience … (to) fervently implore the interposition of the Almighty hand to heal the wounds of the nation.”
I think it’s fair to say he did not succeed in this healing.
A few more bits of the specifically American Thanksgiving history:
- Seven years after Lincoln’s proclamation, Ulysses S. Grant signed Thanksgiving into law as a yearly federal holiday.
- Fifteen years after that, Congress gave paid leave to federal employees for this day, and other federal holidays.
- However, in 1939, Franklin Roosevelt moved Thanksgiving’s official date, making it a week earlier; the third, rather than the fourth, Thursday in November.
- Roosevelt believed this would amp up Christmas-related retail sales; it being the tail-end of the Depression, this was seen as a good thing
- (Witnessing today’s “Black Friday” Consumer Gorge-a-Thon, one sees Roosevelt’s prescient logic).
- Of course there was a big hoo-hah at the time about him changing the date; his political opponents said he was a chaotic flip-flopper, etc,.
- Finally, in 1941, Congress settled it, fixing Thanksgiving on the fourth Thursday of November.
Please note: the official day on which American’s Thanksgiving is celebrated jumped around. This is essential to my next point.
MORE ON ANSWER B
B’S Take-Away: THERE IS NO INHERENT, ESSENTIAL REASON THANKSGIVING HAS TO TAKE PLACE ON A CERTAIN DAY!
This may seem minor, but it is potentially really important in making Thanksgiving work smoothly for all concerned. So very much more smoothly than if you celebrate on the same day most people are! 
If you choose to host Thanksgiving on any non-official day, you and your guests:
- can save money by avoiding the notorious jacked-up holiday airplane fares
- can avoid the stress of sold-out flights and nightmarishly crowded airports
- can also avoid the stress and expense of sold-out, holiday-rate hotel rooms (in case you have out-of-town company due in, whom you cannot put up in your home)
- can also avoid crowded roadways, sometimes heightened by fuel shortages and/or. often, the first seriously inclement weather of the season
- can end or diminish custody and familial loyalty/turf battles about who spends the holiday where: with which parent or set of in-laws… no more having to choose or make others have to choose; no more proxy fights about who loves who the most
- have the option of selecting the most convenient possible day for you and those you’re celebrating with
- are able to shop at supermarkets that are not mobbed, with long check-out lines, and the disappointment of discovering your favorite food or wine is sold out
Now of course there is one problem with this loosey-goosey approach: the fourth Thursday of November is the official holiday, hence a paid day-off for those who work (other than the self-employed).
And schools, too, are closed, so students, too, are excused and will not miss classes. These official closures make it easy in one sense, but not transportation- or expense-wise: because almost everyone else is trying to do it on the official date.
BUT if you fall outside of these demographics, or are willing to take a day or two off from work or school, then making the day you celebrate Thanksgiving any day that works is so very easy.
Unbelievably easy! Just removes so many of the stresses inherent in celebrating at the same moment almost everyone else is (I learned this lesson, in part, from 18 years as an innkeeper. Since then, I always travel in the off- or shoulder-season; see shows or eat in restaurants midweek, not weekends; much better service and more options).
Also, since, as mentioned, I have outlived all but one of my blood relations, I celebrate the day with my chosen family of friends. Since most of them have living relatives, some of whom are nit-picky about where and with whom they, my pals, spend the official day, I start checking in with my friends gently at summer’s end.
In recent years, the Dragonwagon-Graff-hosted Thanksgiving has taken place any time between November 10 and November 29. Most of those we love get to come, and they don’t have to choose between us and their families… who have been known to employ the guilt-trip if they don’t attend on the official day.
Everything? Or almost everything?
To celebrate Thanksgiving truthfully, joyfully, and with integrity, I’ve had to let go of the sweet, hopeful, but patently false grade-school story with which I, and most likely you, grew up. This story, and the horrible bittersweet truth that is also part of this holiday, is something we’ll explore inupcoming Days of Thanksgiving posts.
But, while Maya Salam titled her masterful 2017 New York Times article, “everything you learned about Thanksgiving is wrong,” I disagree, respectfully.
Not “everything” we learned is wrong.
After all, we “learn” not only in school, and from stories passed on verbally, but around the tables of the homes in which we grew up.
There, we study through absorbing. We learn, by living, the nature of our family’s get-togethers, and hospitality styles, and cooking, and maybe, if we’re lucky, gardening.
We learn that there are special days we call holidays, which have their own rituals and traditions. If we have friends or neighbors we’re close to, we learn that every home and table is a little different. And this is neither right nor wrong; it just is.
How can one holiday’s meaning and history be drenched both in blood (as we will see) and generosity? Kindness, aspiration, peace and plenty, gratitude — side by side with the most bitter of thefts and betrayals? Can we bear to look open-eyed at the shades of horror that partially color the day historically, as we will in the C and D of our “What is Thanksgiving” multiple choice, and yet, find cause for sincere celebration and delight?
Can we bear not to? Are we able to go straight to the contradictory heart of the great and not-so-great American Experiment? To look at what we despise and what we love, and find our own way through it?
I believe we can. I believe we must. And, as I am writing this post in the days leading up to the 2024 election (which is for me, and I believe for most of us, extraordinarily anxiety-provoking), I think that now, right now, presents the perfect time to do so.
Not to resolve our differences, but, however difficult and frightening it is at times, to accept them; to play our part in the great flawed social ecosystem that is our lot as human beings.
To love, anyway. To cultivate faith and hope, alongside fear, anyway. To harvest, anyway.
And sometimes, despite having to crumble and bumble our way through this mysterious adventure known as life, to sit down at the table together, and give thanks.

CRUMBLE-BUMBLE BARS
Equipment
- 8-inch square pan or baking dish
- parchment paper
Ingredients
- oil or spray oil for greasing pan
- 1 1/4 cup unbleached white flour
- 1 1/4 cup wholewheat flour, preferably wholewheat pastry flour
- 1 cup rolled oats (not instant oatmeal)
- 1/2 cup dark brown sugar, or coconut sugar, packed
- 1/4 cup sugar, preferably raw or turbinado (but white will do)
- 1 1/4 teaspoons baking powder
- 1/4 teaspoon table salt, preferably fine sea salt...
- 1 cup minus 1 tablespoon butter, melted If you are using unsalted butter, add an extra 1/4 teaspoon salt. Also, 1 cup minus 1 tablespoon equals 15 tablespoons, or, by weight, 212 grams.
- 1 1/2 teaspoons vanilla extract
- 2 to 2 1/2 cups Green Tomato Mincemeat (or another thick, cooked filling, of a jam-like consistency)
Instructions
- Preheat the oven to 375°F, with a rack in the center or lower third of oven. Line the pan with parchment, using two pieces placed across each other perpendicularly, so that the pan is lined on all sides (this keeps the filling from sticking to the pan, which it otherwise tends to do). Then, with either spray oil or a bit of oil on a paper towel, lightly grease the parchment paper.
- In a large bowl, toss flour, rolled oats, sugars, baking powder, and salt together, using tour fingers to smoosh out any lumps of brown sugar.
- Add the vanilla and melted butter, and stir together with hands or a spoon until all ingredients are evenly combined. This is your cookie dough.
- Transfer about 2/3 of this dough to the parchment-lined pan. Press it firmly into a nice even layer, and spoon the Green Tomato Mincemeat (or other filling, if desired) over it, also as evenly as possible.
- Toss the remaining dough (it'll be about 1 1/3 cups) again, using your fingers to crumble and squeeze it: you can make bigger or finer crumbles or clumps. Sprinkle these crumbs of dough over the filling as evenly as possible, mostly hiding that fragrant filling. But perfect coverage is not essential.
- Lower the oven temp to 350, and bake the bars for 50 to 60 minutes. The top crumbles should be slightly browned and baked through; the kitchen will be fragrant.
- When the bars are cool, lift them from the pan by using the parchment to pull up. Like "a sling," say the King Arthur Flour people, in their version. Slice and serve.
- The sliced Crumble-Bumbles will keep at room temp for a day or two in an airtight container; refrigerate them for up to four days, or or freeze them if you want to keep them longer.
P.S. Did you know I have a Deep Feast page on Facebook, too? Recipes, cookbook reviews, kitchen table talk, adventures in cooking and eating and restaurant-going… I invite you to follow me there, too. I just posted a series of photos showing how to criss-cross line the pan for the Crumble-Bumbles with 2 sheets of parchment, as described above.
