CD’s ICED OPEN SESAME COOKIES

HOSPITALITY VIA COOKIE.

MEET THE MOST UNPREPOSSESSING-LOOKING, WHOLLY DELICIOUS — ONE MIGHT EVEN SAY ADDICTIVE — COOKIE KNOWN TO HUMANKIND: THESE UGLY ICED SESAME SEED COOKIES.


I seem to have lost the picture I have of Craig as Easter Bunny Breakfast Deliverer… but here’s Ned, my darling late husband, in the role. Edward, one of our front desk guys, is in the back.

CRAIG, A NOT-SEEDY CHARACTER 

Back during the eighteen years my late husband and I owned Dairy Hollow House, a country inn and restaurant in Eureka Springs, Arkansas, a man named Craig worked for us for a couple of years.

Friendly, shambling, easy-going, good-natured, a little shy: that was Craig, who worked for us behind the scenes at the inn, filling in as needed.

If memory serves, Craig mostly acted as an occasional dishwasher and now-and-then odd-job doer. He did deliver the breakfast baskets to the guest rooms a few mornings, including once on Easter. This required the basket-deliverer to wear ears and a cotton-tail (Ned usually did this, but one year he was either sick or out of town; Craig, somewhat sheepishly, stepped — or hopped —in as a replacement delivery bunny).

Again, if memory is doing its job, Craig also worked part-time driving one of the Eureka Springs city trolleys. These were mostly used by tourists, and responding probably also enlarged Craig’s sweet, friendly go-with-the-flow skill-set.

Now. Although Craig was only briefly part of that happy and hospitable madness that running the inn required, I remember him clearly and fondly, for two reasons.

1. He was just so affable.

2. And, those sesame cookies he made a couple of times. Those sesame cookies!

For odd-jobbing at the inn did now and then involved Craig’s making cookies.  And the cookies he made? None of the recipes we made in regular rotation. Instead, those sesame cookies. So good that the memory of them haunted me for more than three decades, until I finally, finally, found what I believe to have been his recipe.

Though I have called this version of them “CD’s”, and I did indeed ring a few fundamental twists on them, still: their DNA lies with Craig.

And Craig had had help. From a certain iconic fictional character, who has put in an appearance in countless American kitchens.  I am sure you, too, know her: Betty Crocker.


SAYING “HELLO, WELCOME ” AND “GOODBYE, SO GLAD YOU CAME”  —- VIA COOKIE

Now one of the things we did at Dairy Hollow House was cookies.

And we did them well.

Though the inn closed in 1999, to this day former guests with whom I’m still in touch occasionally recall to me the inn’s various cookies. There’s usually a tone of  longing in their words, and, when I am being in told in person, as opposed to on social media, I often hear often a sigh of happy-sad pleasure: As if a golden era, a Camelot that is no more, is being remembered.

Two of the hundreds of the individually personalized holiday cookies I iced for December Dairy Hollow House guests.

See, unless incoming guests had told us they were gluten-free or didn’t eat sweets, when they checked into their room, they’d find a plate with two freshly-baked cookies… Two giant, clearly homemade cookies on a plate, tightly covered with film, waiting for them in their room. And when they took a bite, they discovered those cookies were really good.

The check-in cookies were always a chocolate-chocolate chip cookie.

Then, for each day of a guest’s stay, there’d be a different kind of cookie waiting in their room. Lemon bars, butterscotch brownies, decadent date-nut delights. And, during the December holidays, gingerbread hearts with each guest’s name piped, labor intensively I must add,  in white icing.

All these were among the Dairy Hollow House cookie repertoire.

The final set of cookies were handed over to guests as they last checked out: two good old-fashioned comforting oatmeal cookies. We passed them across the front desk, folded into a bag, with wash-and-dry towelettes and napkins. For, we hoped, pleasurable on-the-way-home eating.

I must confess that these goodbye cookies were my idea. Because I had noticed, over the years, that the amount of time guests took off for vacations was growing shorter and shorter, and given some thought to this. When we first opened the inn, a five-day stay was not unusual, and on three-day weekends people always stayed the full three days. But within ten or twelve years, we noticed this changing. Often, guests told us, they’d really had to do some major personal or professional negotiation to have even a two-day Friday-Saturday stay away from work and family obligations. Indeed, I even dug around in hospitality industry stats of the time, which bore this out. The time Americans spent on vacation time was shrinking.

Those date-nut bars, from the earliest Dairy Hollow House days; I still make ’em. This holiday box for my sister-in-law went out to her last year.

I thought this was sad. I started considering: how could we help guests make the most of these shorter stays? If the trip was shorter chronologically, was it possible to make it longer psychologically?

i was always asking myself questions like this; it was part of my non-academic, experiential understanding of hospitality; learning while on the job.

I decided the only way to extend the guest experience was through increasing anticipation beforehand, and making sure there were plenty of over-the-top delighted memories at the other.

What could we offer incoming guests to look forward to before they even arrived? We tried hard to be extra kind, upbeat and helpful when taking reservations, and we kept our promises — confirmation letters went our promptly, in those pre email days; and our brochure was really pretty, carefully written (it took me longer to write the copy for that brochure than it did fotr me to write my whole first novel: I’m not kidding!).

All by way of, we hoped, letting guests know before they arrived that they would be in good hands.

And then, of course, we worked to make the stay itself wonderful, with small beneficial surprises at many turns (not just cookies, but, for example, personalized menus in the breakfast baskets, with “things to do” suggestions, in those pre-internet days, that showed guests their innkeepers had been paying attention to them and vibed out their interests).

And then, on the guests’ departure: those homey oatmeal cookies. To extend the experience just a tiny bit longer.


THE INN’S COOKIE-CREATORS

Mostly, our cookies were made by me or one of the breakfast chefs. We’d make a huge batch of dough, shape it into cookies, freeze the dough balls or patties. And then the Dairymaids — our housekeepers — would bake them off as needed for arriving guests.

Given the location of the oven and kitchen in proximity to the front desk, this also meant that guests often checked in to the scent of baking cookies; if not the cookies, then bread or roasting game hens, or some part of dinner at our restauran. This was another part of my vision of expanding and extending the guest experience. Look, I couldn’t have told you how much profit I’d want the inn to show at year’s end; I was very financially and business literate. But I was sensually wide-awake,  well-read, and I really cared that those who visited us have a good experience. I could tell you exactly how I wanted guests to feel, what I wanted them to inhale when they walked in, (“Mmmm… something smells really good!”)

But, for some long-forgotten reason, one day it was Craig who made the batch of cookie dough, not me or Sandy.

Did he ask to do this? Was someone sick? I don’t remember. What I do remember is that rather than one of our recipes in regular rotation (usually a classic cookie I’d messed with a little), Craig chose a recipe, in a beaten-up somewhat retro cookbook he’d brought in…

I remembered it being something like an early Betty Crocker or a Better Homes & Gardens cookbook. I remembered its vivid, 1960’s-ish colors and not-too-attractive photographs, very much of the era. I remember it had a spiral binding. And I remember being a little dubious.

A sesame plant, with such delicate beautiful bell-shaped flowers. Who knew? This image is from Thomas Jefferson’s garden at Monticello.

And what kind of cookie did he make from it?

Sesame seed cookies.

????

They were not particularly pretty. With some misgiving, I tasted one; in memory, with Craig hovering nearby. Of course, as a business-owner I liked to encourage our employees when they showed initiative. But could these unattractive-looking and odd cookies, possibly be worth presenting to inn guests?

Well. They were fabulous. I had never had anything like them, yet they were instantly pleasing; perfect.

“Oh, Craig,” I said. He beamed.

They were not like sesame cookies that I’ve had in Savannah, the crisp tiny ones I’ve heard called “benne biscuits.”  (Benne is closely related Malinke word for sesame, bĕne; like the seed itself, it is of African origin, probably sub-Saharan). Those Savannah benne biscuits are, in my view, a good but not great cookie; sort of a sweet cracker.

Craig’s sesame cookies were larger, thicker and round. They were sort of like a very good sugar cookie, a little crisp on the edges, a little chewy and soft in the middle.

But the sesame gave them a haunting, lovely flavor, hard to identify but near-addictive.

And they were iced, with a golden-brown sesame-studded icing. The icing just kind of made them, I thought.

I do remember asking Craig about them and him telling me that the secret was you browned the sesame seeds in butter. Then you put some of the toasty golden seeds and their butter in the batter, and used the remainder in the icing.

Intriguing.

But alas, I did not copy the recipe at the time, or note the exact name of the retro cookbook.

But every so often, long after the inn was closed, I craved that toasted sesame, buttery sweet but not too sweet cookie.

As Dr. Google became an omnipresent part of our lives, it occurred to me that surely I could do a search and find that recipe. Surely it would be somewhere on line. Surely, I’d thought, I could find ’em somewhere online, especially as I recalled they’d been in a classic popular American cookbook.

But no luck: I did a search several times, but nada. Then I tried inventing them out of memory’s hole-filled cloth, but again, not it: good-but-not-great category.

I had no idea where to find that recipe, or, for that matter — 27 years later — Craig.


A SLIGHTLY FRUSTRATED SESAME-LOVER

That terrific brand of halvah, that got me back on the sesame cookie hunt… Photograph, Seed and Mill.

Well, it happens that I adore sesame, including its iteration, via tahini (ground sesame seeds)  as an ingredient in salad dressings, and sauces. Tahini, tamari, lemon juice — that is the basis for one of the best dressings you can imagine.

I also keep a bottle of toasted sesame oil in the fridge, to finish Asian-style stir-fries. And of course, the famous Chinese street food, dan-dan noodles, which owe their addictive oomph largely to toasted sesame (backed up with peanuts, herbs, a little sugar or honey, chile, and tamari).

And I love the sesame confection known as as halvah, a very sweet, flaky-textured candy that’s widely eaten throughout the Middle East, North Africa, the Balkans, and Central and South Asia. I remember my grandparents, Russian Jews, eating halvah. Halvah is often described as fudge-like, but it is neither as teeth-on-edge sweet as are most fudges, and its texture differs.

Well, all of a sudden our local co-op began carrying a really excellent artisanal halvah, made by a company called Seed and Mill.

I bought a small box, and I have to confess, I ate it much more quickly and copiously than was probably wise.

And then I bought a second box, which I quickly killed off with my friend KJ.

I think this is what put me in mind, again, of Craig’s sesame cookies.


“UGLY BUT GOOD”

When I got the yen for the long-elusive Iced Sesame Cookies yet again the other day, post-halvah gorging, I decided to consulted Dr. Google again.

After all, years had passed since the last time I looked.

The third time was the charm! I Googled “Iced Sesame Cookies” Eureka!

I was amused to find something that sounded just like the cookies I remembered on a site called Ugly Desserts. I was tickled partly because I remembered, around the time I was researching the Sweet Beans chapter of my book Bean by Bean coming across a recipe for an Itlian meringue cookie called Brutti ma Buoni, which translates to Ugly But Good Cookies. Surely, I thought, the Ugly Desserts blog must be related.

The minute I saw Cameron’s reference to the book, I hit Dr. Google again. Yes! This was definitely it. And talk about retro — I don’t think anyone spells “cooky” like this any more. It was first published in 1963.

But it wasn’t. Its creator, San Franciscan Cameron Weston, explains that when he was growing up, his family always had a holiday party on Christmas Eve. “People would come and help decorate our tree and my mom would cook a lot of desserts…   Drinks flowed pretty freely (for my parent’s friends, not us kids), and it was all around a lot of fun.”  When he went out on his own, he decided to continue the tradition.

Why “ugly” desserts?

“I can make desserts that are amazingly delicious, ” writes Cameron. “I know this, and I’m confident in it. What I can’t do…is make them look good. They almost never look like the desserts you see in magazines, or bakeries…or blogs like this. And I’m telling you right now – that’s ok. It’s better than ok. I’m not trying to make the world’s most beautiful desserts. I’m trying to make stuff that people really, really want to eat.”

That certainly applied to the cookies I was remembering so longingly. And when Cameron further explained, “I was leafing through a dessert cookbook a good friend gave me as a gift and I found a recipe for sesame seed cookies. The cookbook is an old one – Betty Crocker’s Cooky Book and it’s kind of a trip.  There are a ton of old-timey recipes in there, some of which I would never make, but some – like the sesame seed cookie one – I think are pretty interesting.”

He notes, “I didn’t change this recipe a whole lot (a little, but not a lot), so definitely credit where credit is due, to Ms. Betty Crocker. ”

Of course I tried it. Of course I definitely messed around with it a little, because 1) that’s how I roll, and  2) I wanted to amp the sesame up a bit.

Originally, the cookie was made with all butter; I substituted tahini for part of this, and added a tablespoon of my beloved toasted sesame oil. Wow, wow, wow!

And I have been very, very pleased with the results. And I hope you will be, too.

But don’t say I didn’t warn you: they are addictive.

Print

CD'S IMPOSSIBLY GOOD ICED OPEN SESAMES:

Hauntingly delicious, sweet but not too sweet, these cookies are as delectable as they are "meh" in appearance. But so what?
Course Dessert
Cuisine American
Servings 20 cookies

Ingredients

Cookie ingredients

  • 3/4 cup butter, divided
  • 1/3 cup sesame seeds
  • 1 tablespoon toasted sesame oil
  • 1/4 cup tahini, oil stirred into solids
  • 1 cup sugar
  • 1 large egg
  • 1 1/2 teaspoons vanilla
  • 2 cups unbleached white flour
  • 1 teaspoon baking powder
  • 1/2 teaspoon baking soda
  • 1/4 teaspoon salt

Icing

  • 3 cups powdered sugar, sifted
  • 1 tablespoon butter or toasted sesame oil softened to room temperature
  • 1/4 cup milk, added a tablespoon at a time
  • 1 1/2 teaspoons vanilla

Instructions

Cookies

  • Preheat oven to 375 degrees Fahrenheit.
  • Put the 1/2 cup butter and sesame seeds into a small saucepan, and heat over medium low heat. Stirring near-constantly, melt the butter and let the sesame seeds turn a nice golden brown, 3-4 minutes. Watch carefully, otherwise they will burn quickly and you'll have to start over. Once they are done, remove the pan from the heat, stir in the toasted sesame oil, and set aside to cool slightly.
  • In a large bowl, beat the room temperature butter and tahini until well-combined. Beat in the sugar, until well-combined and fluffy, then add the egg and vanilla , and keep beating until well-blended. Add 3 heaping tablespoons of the browned sesame seed/butter mixture and stir again, saving the remainder sesame seed/butter mixture - for the icing.
  • In a separate medium bowl, whisk together the flour, baking powder, baking soda, and salt. Stir them into the wet ingredients in the large bowl until well blended, but don't overbeat.
  • Gather the cookie dough and shape it into a cylindrical or rectangular roll. Slice the dough into 1/4 to 1/3 inch slices and place the cookie slices onto a cookie sheet lined with parchment paper, laying them 1 to 1 1/2 inches apart; they don't spread much.
  • Bake for 8-10 minutes or until the bottoms and sides are lightly browned. To ensure bottoms are lightly brown, flip one cookie over on the pan. Once they are lightly brown, remove the cookies from the oven, let the cookies rest on the pan for about 5 minutes and then move them to a wire rack to cool completely.
  • While the cookies are cooling, make your icing.

Icing

  • In a large bowl mix the powdered sugar, butter, 1 tablespoon milk, the vanilla, and all of the remaining sesame seed/butter mixture. Blend until well combined. Although Cameron makes his icing thick and spreadable, I prefer it thinner. I add milk a little at a time, until it is of a drip-able consistency.
  • Once the cookies are cool, place a sheet to catch the drips beneath the rack, and ice the cookies generously. Serve at room temperature. The cookies freeze well, too, and are sturdy enough to mail.

9 thoughts on “CD’s ICED OPEN SESAME COOKIES”

    1. Crescent Dragonwagon

      Thank you! And I am so excited about our GLISTENS project… moving a little more slowly than I’d like (thanks to excess busyness on my part AND — the really awful kicker — all the unknowns vis a vis tariffs, because most books are published in China, and I have to wait until things are less volatile and more settled down before I can even get a price and know that it’s possible). But: I digress. I, and we, and Across the Sky, will make this happen, though I don’t immediately known when ore how. But I imagine a little thing like that’s never stopped either of us.

  1. 5 stars
    Love the story and can’t wait to try the recipe. Your details are marvelous, especially on the icing! Wonderful meeting you at Tybee Island with Rosemary Daniell a couple years ago and enjoying some fabulous meals!

    1. Crescent Dragonwagon

      I LOVED my time at Tybee with Rosemary and the gang (other than my first and I sincerely hope last) interaction with that jellyfish! I hope our paths cross again, Estelle, and let me know what youy think of these cookies.

  2. Houston Harrison

    5 stars
    When a great storyteller describes a great recipe, you have no choice but try it! Let me just say that this recipe lives up to its legendary status and you might just want to give it a whirl!

  3. 5 stars
    I made a batch of these to take to Easter soup supper yesterday. More now than ever, ugly is as ugly does, and these taste beautiful.

Comments are closed.

Scroll to Top