Why are some saved and some lost?
Once a month most months, I make the round-trip drive from Westminster West,Vermont to Hastings-on-Hudson, New York (where I spend a week with my 97-year-old mother, Charlotte Zolotow). Leave Vermont, cross Massachusetts, cross Connecticut, reach New York. And then reverse it.
Exit after exit, I read the names of the towns and have semi-mindless associations. Chappaqua, New York; Hillary and Bill Clinton, who have a home there. Pleasantville, New York, where my late Aunt Dot’s late long-time companion, Jim, had a home. Elmsford, New York; that Persian restaurant I like.
Last Thursday, December 13, 2012, I was coming up 84 to Hartford, had almost reached the point in the tangle of lanes where I knew I needed to get to the right to pick up 91 North. Had passed the Connecticut exits with their associations: Waterbury, where I once got fuel, drove off without removing my wallet from where it was resting on the car, and, miraculously, someone turned it in to the local police and I was able to pick it up intact from them. Newtown; I once stopped at an “easy-on easy-off” diner there late at night and had some really not-good lemon meringue pie. Meriden; where someone I once dated briefly, lived.
Usually I drive the late model Subaru Forester, but occasionally I drive the crap car: a 2001 Dodge Neon, so low-end that it actually has roll-up (with a crank) windows. I was driving the crap car on Thursday.
It was almost rush-hour as I approached Hartford, a time/place continuum I try hard to avoid on this commute. There was more traffic than I prefer, but I’d still be on the other side of Hartford before it hit full spate. I changed lanes to position myself for the split to 91 North, braking slightly.
I considered for maybe 3 seconds trying to pull off on the nearest ramp and get to a service station.
Then, in far less time than it takes to write this account, I ran the impossible odds of being able to end up at a service station without hitting anyone or anything, from an unknown exit, near rush hour, in downtown Hartford.
I realized, “NO.”
I was in the right lane. I pulled off onto the shoulder — narrow, but wide enough — and glided to a stop. Safely.
I put on the flashers. I called a friend. I called Triple-A. I got right through to Roadside Assistance; when they learned where I was on 91 they took it seriously. “We’re putting you on the top of the list.”
I called another friend. I sat in my car, waited for the tow-truck. I was not yet shaking at my close call, though the car shook with each 18-wheeler that passed. I was relatively still, against the loud white noise of the non-stop traffic stream. I simply couldn’t believe I was fine. Alive, unhurt, had not hurt anyone else, had not even dented the crap car.
And I was overwhelmed by gratitude and amazement.
The rest of the story — how I got home, the nice guys at Cameron’s Auto Service, who picked up the repaired crap car the next day— does not really matter.
What matters is, there I was, swimming — that day and the next — in astonished gratitude that my life had been spared in Hartford, Connecticut.
And then I heard the news: the massacre in Newtown.
Many other lives, twenty of them the lives of six- and seven-year-olds, had not been spared.
I can make no sense of any of this, on any level. While Rilke advises us to “be patient towards all that is unanswered in your heart, and learn to love the questions themselves,” there are some questions, the most profound and fundamental “why” questions, which are not lovable. Towards which we cannot, should not, and must not be patient.
On one level, the “why” in the case of this slaughter must be addressed. Guns, and the culture of violence so prevalent and glorified in America. Guns and their licensing, or lack of same: I just don’t GET why you have to take a test (not only written but in an actual vehicle, with a policeman no less), to get a drivers license; then document, tag and title, at each and every point of sale, and then get insurance, for a car, which is a transportation machine (though it can certainly kill you) but not for a gun, which is a killing machine (though it cannot transport you anywhere, except, possibly, to the next world). Mental health care, and access to it. Causal factors in mental health, including funding cuts not only to clinics and veteran’s hospitals, but to programs like Head Start; nutrition and the prevalence of fast food and its effects on mental and emotional state, violence and abuse in the home, and education.
And… the NRA.
Lord knows these “whys” are complex enough, and faceted, and interrelated.
That’s the great lesson of ecology: everything affects everything else. As conservationist John Muir is said to have stated, “Pull any thread in nature and the whole unravels.” Humans are part of nature. Pull the thread of a human action, sacred or profane, horrific or heroic, and our understanding begins to unravel, growing forever more perplexing…
And “there” (as I thought,listening to the Newtown news on NPR) “there but for fortune go I.”
But even if we could address these sorts of “whys” in the case of this massacre, could alter the legislative, economic and behavioral factors that led to Newtown — which will now forever bear the crosses of these murdered innocents, which will now forever twist the hearts of even those who casually pass the green and white sign announcing its exit off 84 — the bigger why remains.
Why are some saved and some lost?
And this is the one that can never, ever even provisionally be answered. (Unless you are Mike Huckabee, who explained that what happened in Sandy Hook is due to prayer having been ‘removed’ from schools.) Wipe out school violence tomorrow, and you are still left with the families who lost their children in Newtown, who must live forever in an ‘after’ they had no idea was coming when they got up that morning, made French toast, bundled small arms into sweaters, lifted small back-packs onto small, dear shoulders. The waves of grief spread out and out forever. The circles of grief never stop widening.
I just don’t get how our wonderful, gorgeous, one and only world can be so chockablock with hate, evil, ignorance, violence. But, how can anyone get it? It is ungettable.
That being so, what do we do with such events?
I think the trick — one I so have not come anything close to mastering — is to stay permeable to the world in all its agony and beauty.
Permeable, responsive on a practical level whenever and however we can… and yet “immunized emotionally” to the extent that
we don’t wholly lose our equipoise no matter what.
And when we lose it, as we will, as we must, as we should, in response to things like the deaths at Sandy Hook… Well, I used to have a yoga teacher who would say, on the tricky balance poses as half the class was falling over, “Let your coming and out of the pose be part of the pose.”
I think it has to be like that. When we inevitably, and often properly, lose our equipoise, we let that — that sorrow, that lack of balance — “be part of the pose.” And return to the reaching for balance. Not achieving it; just reaching for it.
Not blocking out the world; yet neither so losing ourselves in its infinite painful and horrific 24/7 news cycle, the endless stories, both new and repeated, that we are flattened and incapacitated.
Not easy. But the alternatives (being flattened by pain or hardening one’s heart to it, becoming impermeable) are worse.
My own brush with mortality the day before filled me with gratitude; the news of the innocents’ deaths, so nearby, the following day, with heaviness, despair.
Yet in one sense both tell the same story: that our lives are on loan to us, and may be recalled at any time.
That the veil between life and death is opaque, and paper-thin.
That, in the end, we must make our lives worthy of the privilege of having been given this precious loan.
That we must stay permeable, the better to do whatever work has our name on it. That this work should be as generous as is the mysterious gift of our individual loaned lives.
And the ‘what does one do with such events’ question takes on another dimension if we are writers.
We must write about this, however imperfectly and inadequately. We must try to speak the unspeakable.
It is the tiniest of ways we can not let those small bright lives have been wasted.
Talya Tate Boerner says
thanks for all and that poem is astounding. love and light, c
Priscilla King says
I’m glad you were saved.
I think what we can learn from the Newtown murders is that people who are using SSRI’s, especially for “autism spectrum disorders,” should be closely supervised at all times; 5 to 10 percent of all users of these drugs are ticking bombs. (And if guns aren’t available, yes, they’ll use cars, or bombs, or fire, or any heavy object, or their own two feet–in Alexandria, Virginia, a young female patient stomped a stranger to death.)
OK, I’m off my soapbox now.
I’m glad you still have CZ. I’m glad CZ still has you. I’m glad those of us who’ve enjoyed either or both of your books still have this blog.
art and lemons says
This is simply beautiful, Crescent. Thank you. So glad you are okay. In the “it’s a small world” department, one of the children killed was the grandson of a Fayetteville man. I will use your terminology that we are indeed “on loan” here.
Crescent, very thoughtful post, thank you. To one of the other commenters, conjecture and spouting unfounded statistics about people with neurological disorders or mental illness is not helpful. It is harmful. There has been zero credible evidence that the gunman was taking any medications. This kind of bigotry and fearmongering hurts people with autism and mental illness by causing people to discriminate against them, bully them, and lobby lawmakers to take away their rights.
Just came across this amazing column. I notice, though, that the credit for Wislawa Syzmborska’s poem is somewhat obscure, although the translators are clearly credited. I assume, of course, it’s an inadvertent oversight and thought you might want to fix it.